I'm on a roll with this issue of Saveur. This is the Russian Punch Cake (Russische Punschtorte) from the latest issue. According to the magazine, "The hallmarks of this elegant layer cake are a creamy custard filling and a meringue frosting."
You can probably tell I haven't been doing much decorating recently. This cake, which is supposed to be divided into 16 pieces, ended up being a 20 piece cake. Ooops. I did the circles first, but in retrospect I should have done the lines first. Why that didn't occur to me beforehand just shows you how out of practice I am.
I want to know what makes this cake Russian. The layers are brushed with rum, hardly a Russian drink. Maybe it's the meringue icing resembling the snow in Siberia? If anyone knows, please fill me in on this mystery.
While I didn't have any major difficulty with the cake, I pity anyone without baking experience who tried to follow Saveur's recipe. For starters, the recipe didn't state what type of flour to use. I used cake flour, since in my mind that is what a pastry shop would use (although a pastry shop in Vienna may use flour unobtainable to the home cook in the U.S.). The results could be wildly different with all-purpose flour. Also, the cake baked up pretty flat and was hard to cut in three layers. I'm not great at the genoise style of cake where eggs provide all of the structure and lift (that's right, no baking powder or soda!), but I'm sure most home bakers face the same problem of deflating the batter too much when folding in the flour and butter. I think it would have been much better as an 8 inch cake rather than a 9 inch one. However, I FINALLY cut straight layers! Maybe I am getting the hang of this baking thing. Or not.
Here's what the cake is supposed to look like. I tried to make the little honey or sugar "D"s, since it is my initial, but didn't have a fine enough tip on my squeeze bottle so I just made circles, which don't show up well in the photo. Also, I didn't have any candied violets left, so I used blueberries, which I think worked okay. My torch is pretty powerful so I burned a few spots, but it looks like the pros at Demel scorched a few places too, so I don't feel too bad.
This cake looks pretty impressive but the taste is just so-so. The pastry cream is very bland (although it set up nicely with the addition of gelatin), the cake is pretty ordinary (but it is brushed with rum, which is never a bad thing), and the meringue icing had waay too much starch in it and you could taste it. It is my favorite, an Italian meringue, which means that the egg whites are beaten to soft peaks with some of the sugar, but most of the sugar is added as 240 degree syrup whipped into the whites, then beaten until cooled. The texture produced with this method can't be beat, and it pipes like a dream. The best part, of course, is that you can whip out the propane torch and play with fire! This recipe called for 1/2 cup of powdered sugar as the initial sugar used to whip the whites, plus it called for 1 1/2 teaspoons each cornstarch and cream of tarter, which I found excessive. I think next time I'll just use my standard Italian meringue recipe (from Rose Levy Berenbaum). No doubt the starch was added to stabilize the meringue for piping and add to its shelf life, but those concerns don't bother me.
Overall I'd give this recipe a C+, but doubt I'll make it again. It is quite time consuming, as one would expect, and not quite worth all the effort. Next up is the chocolate truffle torte, once I buy a gallon of cream (I exaggerate, but I do need several cups of cream for that one).
Following are photos of the cake making stages I suffered through gladly accomplished.
First is a photo of the pastry cream after chilling. It is quite stiff and worked well between the layers. It needed more vanilla, though. Maybe my vanilla bean was a little too dried up.
This is why I always sift my cake flour when making something delicate like this. You can see the little cake flour "pellets" left in the sifter.
Note how holey this cake turned out. I don't know what I did wrong here! Since this was a genoise with no leavening other than eggs, I didn't want to rap the cake pan on the counter to get out any bubbles! But, for once, I cut layers straight (if not even). Hooray!
The layers are brushed with rum. To me using straight liquor is a bit harsh. I like it better when the alcohol is boiled with a sugar syrup so some of the harshness is tamed. Also, the cake could have used more syrup on it.
Ta da! Straight layers!
Look at how stiff this meringue was:
Not impressive yet. I didn't worry about making it very smooth since I was piping a lot of decoration on it.
The "Leaning Tower of Pisa" school of decorating:
Starting to look a little better here. I need to learn how to count to 16, though.
Fire, baby! I love playing with the torch.